25 Rare GameCube Games for Nintendo Buffs

From Smash Bros to Wind Waker, the GameCube is home to many classic Nintendo titles. Naturally, many of these nostalgic titles are now incredibly valuable. But none are as collectible as the top 25 rare GameCube games.

If you enjoy Nintendo titles, you’ll want to check out this list of the most valuable and rare GameCube games. We used real auction data from the past several years to bring you an up-to-date guide. Not only that, we’ve also included an accurate price range and mini synopsis for each title.

Whether you’re a newbie collector or seasoned veteran, we hope this resource helps. And who knows? You may have some hidden gems lying around.

The 25 Rarest Gamecube Games

Starting at #25, let’s go down the list and check out the most valuable and rare GameCube games around.

25. Gauntlet Dark Legacy

Price: $40 loose – $80 new in box

#25 Rare GameCube Games: Gauntlet
  • Genre: Hack ‘n Slash Dungeon Crawler
  • Developer: Midway Games
  • Release Date: 2002

Originally designed for arcade systems in the early 2000’s, Gauntlet Dark Legacy quickly earned itself a reputation as one of the better Hack ‘n Slash games on the market. This prompted a number of ports, including one for the Nintendo GameCube.

The premise? The mystical Runestones have been stolen by Skorne, an insidious demon with terrible power… and it’s up to you to stop him. Go at it alone or team with friends to retrieve the Runestones and obliterate Skorne and his minions once and for all.

Dark Legacy expands upon the Gauntlet series with new characters, abilities, items, and more. It’s an exciting romp that combines hack ‘n slash and dungeon crawler elements to deliver a polished fantasy adventure.

Although not as popular as the Playstation 2 version, Gauntlet Dark Legacy remains a classic on the GameCube. It’s a must have for collectors of the most valuable GameCube games.

24. Luigi’s Mansion

Price: $25 loose – $100 new in box

Luigi's Mansion
  • Genre: Action-Adventure Horror Game
  • Developer: Nintendo
  • Release Date: 2001

Luigi has won a free mansion! It must be a wonderful stroke of luck, right? Step into the Mushroom Kingdom and you’ll soon realize that something is wrong...

The new mansion is haunted and chock-full of ghosts. Assume control of Luigi as he searches his new home for the devilish beings. Equipped with a special vacuum cleaner known as the Poltergeist 3000, you've got to suck ‘em up and get rid of them, full on Ghostbusters style.

Luigi’s Mansion was released to critical acclaim and has proven itself an excellent addition to the Nintendo line of games. 

23. Kirby Air Ride

Price: $30 loose – $100 new in box

Kirby Air Ride
  • Genre: Racing Game
  • Developer: HAL Laboratory
  • Release Date: 2003

Take to the streets to compete in the City Trial contest. You’ve got just 5 minutes to find a Star vehicle, collect power ups, and get ready for the grand finale racing contest. Think you’re up for the challenge?

Kirby Air Ride is a simple yet challenging game that provides hours of entertainment. Fill the achievement board to unlock new vehicles and maps, then enter LAN mode to try them out against your friends. It’s a grand ‘ol time that provides hours of entertainment and plenty of laughs.

Although Kirby Air Ride didn’t receive great reviews from critics, it’s adored by fans for it’s whimsical style and playful mechanics. It’s also one of the rarest GameCube games on our list, and a highly sought after title all the way around.

22. Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door

Price: $40 loose – $100 new in box

Paper Mario
  • Genre: RPG
  • Developer: Intelligent Systems
  • Release Date: 2004

Are you a fan of the Paper Mario franchise? If so, The Thousand Year Door is one of the best rare Nintendo GameCube games for you.

Take control of Mario as he sets out on a quest to rescue Peach from the villainous X-Nauts organization. Travel across the Mushroom Kingdom in a unique paper-themed game world that boasts a playful mixture of 2D and 3D graphics. Use the environment to your advantage as you take down enemies and return victorious.

Paper Mario goes for up to $100 in new condition, making it one of the most expensive GameCube games on our top 25 list.

21. The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess

Price: $35 loose – $110 new in box

Zelda Twilight Princess
  • Genre: Action-Adventure Game
  • Developer: Nintendo
  • Release Date: 2006

Released towards the end of the GameCube’s lifecycle, The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess has become one of the most rare GameCube games on the market.

This is largely due to its exciting gameplay mechanics that feature your favorite Hylian Hero. Assume control of Link as you set out to save Hyrule from Ganondorf, the evil Gerudo leader. Traverse the lands in search of dungeons as you use your arsenal of powerful equipment to take down your foes and restore peace.

LoZ: Twilight Princess was a smash hit that won numerous accolades, including several Game of the Year awards. It’s the second best-selling Zelda title of all time (behind Breath of the Wild), and it remains a fan favorite on the GameCube.

20. Super Mario Sunshine

Price: $30 loose – $120 new in box

Super Mario Sunshine
  • Genre: Action-Adventure Platformer
  • Developer: Nintendo
  • Release Date: 2002

Uh-oh! Shadow Mario has kidnapped Princess Peach and vandalized Delfino Island. Suit up and assume control of Mario, then embark on a mission to rescue the princess and shed light on the mysterious situation. Run, jump, and flip around the various stages as you take out Bowser’s minions and complete an array of exciting puzzles. Collect 120 Shine Sprites and victory is yours!

The immersive story, exciting mechanics, and fluid gameplay all work together to make this one of the best GameCube games worth money. If you stumble across a copy, be sure to swipe it up.

19. Mario Kart: Double Dash

Price: $30 loose – $130 new in box

Mario Kart Double Dash
  • Genre: Racing Game
  • Developer: Nintendo
  • Release Date: 2003

Are you a fan of the original Mario Kart? If so, Double Dash is sure to delight! Hop into your Kart and compete against characters from the beloved Mario franchise. The twist? You can choose two of your favorite racers, and switch between them during the race.

Sign up for the Grand Prix in 50cc all the way to 150cc. Select your racers, choose your levels, then start your engines! During the match, you’ll need to collect items to gain an advantage over the competition. Unleash volleys of green shells on nearby enemies, or throw out a powerful blue shell to take out first place.

Think you’re a pro? Go for a spin on Rainbow Road and see if you can master the notoriously difficult stage. Double Dash is an excellent addition to the rare GameCube games family, and it’s among the top titles for the platform.

18. Metal Gear Solid: The Twin Snakes

Price: $45 loose – $135 new in box

Metal Gear Twin Snakes
  • Genre: Action-Adventure Stealth Game
  • Developer: Konami
  • Release Date: 2004

If you are a fan of the original Metal Gear Solid, The Twin Snakes is sure to impress. Under the direction of visionary producer Hideo Kojima, this version has been entirely revamped to deliver graphical improvements, new cutscenes, and exciting gameplay enhancements.

Take control of Snake and play through the immersive campaign in third or first-person mode. Carry out the mission as you infiltrate enemy bases with stealthy precision. Should anyone give you any trouble, assassinate them with a precision bullet or rain down fire to show ‘em who’s boss.

The Twin Snakes was released to critical acclaim, and it’s retained a high price tag over the years. That puts it at #18 on our list of the rarest and most expensive GameCube Games!

17. Pokemon XD: Gale of Darkness

Price: $45 loose – $135 new in box

Pokemon XD - One of the Classic Rare GameCube Games
  • Genre: RPG
  • Developer: Genius Sonority
  • Release Date: 2005

Team Cipher has rounded up all the pocket monsters and closed their hearts, turning them into Shadow Pokemon!

Now, it’s up to you to collect and purify all the Shadow Pokemon using the Snag Machine. You’re the only one who stands a chance, and the captured Pokemon are counting on you. Can you muster up the courage to stand against Team Cipher?

Like other Pokemon games, Gale of Darkness has retained its high value over the years. As such, new in box copies go for as much as $135 each! That makes Pokemon XD one of the most valuable GameCube games around.

16. Lost Kingdoms II

Price: $40 loose – $150 new in box

Lost Kingdoms
  • Genre: Action RPG
  • Developer: FromSoftware
  • Release Date: 2003

Long before popular card game titles like Hearthstone and Eternal, there was Lost Kingdoms II. This game combines RPG elements with trading card mechanics to deliver an action adventure full of excitement.

The premise? The protagonist Tara Grimface must embark on a mission to steal powerful Runestones from the Caverns of Kendaria. It’s a journey that includes dangerous battles requiring masterful tactics and powerful cards. And it’ll take all your strategic wits to make it through in one piece.

Although the game received mediocre ratings from critics, it remains a fan favorite title for the GameCube.

15. Skies of Arcadia

Price: $60 loose – $150 new in box

Skies of Arcadia
  • Genre: RPG
  • Developer: Overworks
  • Release Date: 2003

Originally released on the Sega Dreamcast, Skies of Arcadia was completely revamped for its transition to the Nintendo GameCube.

Assume control of Vyse, an air pirate who must voyage across the world to save the planet from the tyrannical Valuan Empire. This turned-based RPG is all about exploration and adventure, with immersive mechanics and a thrilling storyline to match.

While Skies of Arcadia is not widely known, that only adds to its collectibility and value among game hunters and folks seeking the rarest GameCube game.

14. Super Smash Bros. Melee

Price: $30 loose – $220 new in box

Smash Bros Melee - Among the Most Iconic & Rare GameCube Games
  • Genre: HAL Laboratory
  • Developer: Nintendo
  • Release Date: 2001

Super Smash Bros. Melee. Is among the most iconic games on the Nintendo GameCube. It’s the second iteration in the bestselling series, and it absolutely smashes the competition. Play as your favorite Nintendo characters, and duke it out with your friends as you vie for victory. Think you’ve got what it takes to reach the top?

Although Super Smash Bros was one of the best selling GameCube games, it’s a highly sought after title that deserves a spot on the top of our list. If you manage to find a sealed copy, you’re looking at a highly valuable collectible.

13. Resident Evil: 10th Anniversary Collection

Price: $90 loose – $200 new in box

Resident Evil
  • Genre: Survival Horror Game
  • Developer: Capcom
  • Release Date: 2006

The Resident Evil: 10th Anniversary Collection boxed set contains copies of Resident Evil, Resident Evil Zero, and Resident Evil 4. This GameStop exclusive was released to celebrate the original version launch 10 years prior on the Playstation One.

All three of the games are based around bizarre happenings that draw the player in, before quickly escalating. It’s a matter of survival as things go from bad to worse! Pick up your weapon of choice and take aim quickly! It’ll take all you’ve got to make it out of this supernatural horror fest alive.

The 10th Anniversary Collection takes a top spot on our rare GameCube games list largely due to its GameStop exclusivity.

12. Go Go Hypergrind

Price: $80 loose – $230 new in box

  • Genre: Sports Game
  • Developer: Poponchi
  • Release Date: 2003

Go Go Hypergrind is totally righteous, dude!

As you might expect, this GameCube exclusive is centered all around skateboarding. The premise is simple: players select a cartoon character, hop on their favorite board, and take to the halfpipe to perform wacky stunts. Ready to shred?

Contributing to its rarity is the fact that the game was never released in Japan. Moreover, it’s managed to gather a solid following over the past several years, making it one of the rarest Nintendo games on our list.

11. Phantasy Star Online Episode I & II

Price: $80 loose – $250 new in box

Phantasy Star - Rare GameCube Games MMO
  • Genre: MMORPG
  • Developer: Sonic Team
  • Release Date: 2002

Phantasy Star Online was the very first MMORPG for game consoles, and it was a huge commercial success.

Originally a Dreamcast exclusive, Sega was forced to transition the title following the shuttering of their console lineup. And that’s when a port was made for the Nintendo GameCube. Enter Phantasy Star Online Episode I & II.

The GameCube version featured new quests, graphics, and game modes, and was released in 2002 to an entire new audience of gamers. The good news? The transition to GameCube was a hit, and The Phantasy Star series remains a popular franchise that can be found on Nintendo Switch to this very day.

10. Fire Emblem: Path of Radiance

Price: $100 loose – $250 new in box

Fire Emblem
  • Genre: RPG
  • Developer: Intelligent Systems
  • Release Date: 2005

Fire Emblem: Path of Radiance is a challenging RPG that was released for the Nintendo GameCube in 2005, near the end of the console’s mainstream lifecycle.

As part of the Fire Emblem series, Path of Radiance features the same set of iconic characters you know and love. The premise? Assume control of Ike and friends as you battle against enemies across the game world and restore peace to the realm.

The game’s intricate battle mechanics are lauded for their depth, and the title found widespread commercial success across North America.

9. NCAA College Basketball 2K3

​Price: $100 loose – $350 new in box

NCAA 2K3 - One of the Most Difficult to Find Rare GameCube Games
  • Genre: Sports Game
  • Developer: Kush Games
  • Release Date: 2002

Have you been to those game stores that have bargain bins full of retro sports title? If so, you may be confused by this entry to the most expensive GameCube games list. But rest assured, there’s a reason it’s here.

As you probably know, the GameCube was primarily targeted toward a younger audience. As such, sports titles never made much of a dent in sales on the system. But Sega was determined to try its luck anyways, so they released NCAA College Basketball 2K3 in late 2002.

That was a mistake. The game flopped miserably, and Sega pulled the plug halfway through production. Nowadays, finding a copy, particularly one in good condition, is a major challenge.

8. Cubivore

​Price: $125 loose – $400 new in box

  • Genre: Action-Adventure Game
  • Developer: Intelligent Systems
  • Release Date: 2002

Take control of Cubivore as he scours the land in search of other beasts to feed on. Each beast he consumes only adds to his strength, cementing his position at the top of the food chain. It’s eat or be eaten in this crazy adventure title for the GameCube.

Though Cubivore was released multiple times, it remains a top Nintendo title. This is largely due to its unique gameplay and silly mechanics. If you come across an unopened copy, be sure to keep it sealed. But if you come across a loose variant, give it a playthrough. This rare GameCube game is a lot of fun.

7. Gotcha Force

​Value: $130 loose – $400 new in box

Gotcha Force
  • Genre: Shooter
  • Developer: Capcom
  • Release Date: 2003

Earth is under attack, and it’s up to Kou and his friends to stop the enemy invaders and save the planet! Up for the challenge?

Gotcha Force is a third person fighting game designed by CapCom exclusively for the Nintendo GameCube. Unfortunately, the game never really caught on in North America.

Although it wasn’t much of a hit in the retail market, it did manage to gather an enthusiastic cult following. Combine that with its low sales numbers, and Gotcha Force has become a collectible title that commands high prices for loose and new copies alike.

6. Sonic Adventure 2-Pack

​Price: $75 loose – $460 new in box

Sonic 2 Pack
  • Genre: Action-Adventure Game
  • Developer: Sonic Team
  • Release Date: 2002

Sonic Adventure 2-Pack is a combination of Sonic Adventure & Sonic Adventure 2. First released in 1998 for the Dreamcast, the Sonic Adventure series catapulted your favorite blue hero into the 3D mainstream.

The premise? Players assume control of Sonic the Hedgehog and friends as they go on a quest to stop Dr. Robotnik from carrying out his evil plans. You must run, jump, and navigate challenging courses as fast as you can! Time is of the essence, and only you are fast enough to succeed.

What makes this version of Sonic Adventure so rare? Well, the main selling point of this set is the outer box itself, as this is all that separates it from the two individual games inside. If you manage to find a set with the box, hold onto it! It makes an excellent addition to a rare GameCube collection.

5. Disney Sports Basketball

​Price: $100 loose – $600 new in box

Disney Sports
  • Genre: Sports Game
  • Developer: Polygon Magic
  • Release Date: 2002

Disney Sports Basketball lets you shoot hoops with your favorite Disney characters, including the likes of Mickey Mouse, Donald Duck, and Goofy! Jump in and compete against the opposing team to score massive points. Top of the leaderboard wins.

Unfortunately, the game wasn’t much of a slam dunk in terms of sales. Though the GameCube was heavily marketed towards children, the sports genre never really caught on. That makes Disney Sports Basketball a collectible title that continues to increase in value.

4. Pokemon Colosseum (Preorder Edition)

​Price: $100 loose – $600 new in box

Pokemon Colosseum
  • Genre: RPG
  • Developer: Genius Sonority
  • Release Date: 2004

While Pokemon Colosseum is a rare Nintendo GameCube game in and of itself, the Preorder Edition is especially valuable. That’s because it came with a bonus disc, which contained Jirachi: Wish Maker, as well as a downloadable Jirachi for the 3rd generation Game Boy games.

The disc also contained a number of previews for popular and upcoming Nintendo releases. Combined with the fact that it was only available by reservation, Pokemon Colosseum (Preorder Edition) makes an excellent addition to a rare GameCube games collection.

3. The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker & Ocarina of Time Master Quest

​Price: $60 loose – $750 new in box

#3 Rare GameCube Games: Zelda Master Quest
  • Genre: Action-Adventure Game
  • Developer: Nintendo
  • Release Date: 2003

Two of the most iconic games in the Zelda series. In the same box. What more could you possibly ask for?

The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker & Ocarina of Time Master Quest is a combination set of the original GameCube game alongside a revamped copy of the N64 classic. Enter the land of Hyrule to save Princess Zelda and take down Ganon before it’s too late! Using your magical conductor’s baton or ocarina, only you have the power to save the world. Will you answer the call?

This set is highly valuable due to Zelda’s popularity, and the fact that it contains individual discs for each title. One of the coolest rare GameCube games on our list.

2. Pokemon Box

​Price: $250 loose – $1100 new in box

#2 Rare GameCube Games: Pokemon Box
  • Genre: Utility Game
  • Developer: The Pokemon Company
  • Release Date: 2004

Pokemon Box is a training aid designed to work alongside Pokemon Ruby & Sapphire, as well as Pokemon FireRed and LeafGreen. The premise is simple: players are able to store and transfer their Pokemon from the Game Boy handheld system to the GameCube. Then, players can view, organize, and show off their Pokemon via the Pokemon Box application.

What makes Pokemon Box so valuable? Well, the American version of Pokemon Box was only available for sale at the Pokemon Center in New York City. Moreover, there were limited quantities available for purchase. If you find a copy, hang onto it!

1. Metroid Prime & The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker

​Price: $250 loose – $1500 new in box

#1 Rare GameCube Games: Zelda & Metroid
  • Genre: Action-Adventure
  • Developer: Nintendo
  • Release Date: 2005

Play through your favorite Metroid and Zelda games in this 2-in-1 combination set that features Prime and Wind Waker. They’re the same games you know and love, simply packaged together for your convenience.

But if they’re the same games, what makes this combo set so rare?

Well, this particular release was only available during the 2005 holiday season. Moreover, the only way to obtain one was bundled with a full GameCube console. Inside the box you’d find this package, which contains two separate discs and manuals.

The other reason it’s one of the rarest GameCube games around? Metroid Prime and The Wind Waker are two of the most sought after and rare GameCube games on the console. True must-haves for serious collectors.

Leave a Comment

%d bloggers like this: